Yes bro its makrooh becoz its not a valueable thingyea but we are not changing anything in Islam tho .....
Is terhan to bahut si aysi cheezein hain jo Muhammad SAW nay nahi ki laykin ab hum karte hain. (e.g using computer)
Celebrating birthday can be forbidden(makroh/haram) but how it can be biddah ?
and really if you see deeply its nothing but public is
very happy with the day of birth
and its in category of haram becoz not only non muslims
but eesaaiy or yahoodis begin this day's celebration
and we are forbidden for following them
so its haram like this and anyways my brother Muslim
actually meant about celebrating birthday of any ISLAMIC personality
is biddah and haram but may be he forgotted
mentioning becoz I think he was in hurry yester night . . .[DOUBLEPOST=1343720537][/DOUBLEPOST]
Kya mein aapko biddat ke aqsaam bataaun ??shaitaaan mehaz sirf aik sooch hai or kch bi nai , hum khud hum kitni khubsurati se sab kch shaitaan per daal detay hain halaanky gunah -o-sawab k murtakib bi khudi hotay hain ,
Mje yeh batayen k eid milan-un-nabi k siwa or kch bi bidda nazer nai aati kya tum logon ko ??[DOUBLEPOST=1343716462][/DOUBLEPOST]
maine bidaat ki iksaaam puchi hain ?
kya mujhe ijaazat hai ??