Assalam-o-Alaikum
Mere Intehai bhole bhale, seedhe saadhe, aur intehaai shareeful mizaaj Arsalan Attari bhai mai aapki baton ki kiaa daad doon, zubaan ruk jaati hai, aqal dang rah jaati hai, haath tham jaate hain aur shashdar o pareshaani k alam mai sirf yeh kehna chahoonga k Allah Talah aap logon ko aqale saleem ata farmaye aur deen ki baton ko dil aur dimaag khol kar aur Allah aur uskay Rasool SAWW ki baton ko ahmiat dene ki taufeeq ata farmaye, Aameen.
Attari bhai jaan aapki post mai parh rha thaa lekin jawab dene ka mood nahi ho rha thaa kyun k aap ne is tarah ki baten ki hain jo kisi bache ki hoti hain aur jaise koi bacha jawab deta hai aur apne bachkana dalael de kar manane ki koshish karta hai aur agar bare usay sach bataen to wo apni baat par hi qaim rahta hai aur zid karta hai bilkul isi tarah aap ne batain ki hain aur Quran shareef aur sahi ahadees ki hawala jaat saamnay daikhne k baad b aap k kaan par joon tak na raingi hai aur aap murg ki aik taang k mutaradif apni baat par atal hain.
Arsalan Attari bhai sahab aap ne jo birthday wali baat ki hai us par to mai shashdar hoon k aap ne yeh kiaa baat ki hai, O mere bhai jaan saray maslak k ulamaa is baat par muttafiq hain k Birthday kisi b tarah se jaaiz nahi hai to yeh kia baat hui k aap Abdul Qadir Jilani ki birthday mana rahe ho yeh aap nay daleel di hai date aur month ko fix karne ki wah waaaaaaaaaah kia baat hai aap ki sadqe jaaon.
Meri sheereen mizaaj bhai aap ne jo fatwa yahan paste kia hai, mere bhai aap yeh batana pasand karainge k yeh kin sahab ka hai aur yeh kaisa fatwa hai jis mai aik b Quran ka hawala yaa Saha sitta se koi baat nahi hai aur sirf jaiz hai jaiz hai ki rat lagi hui hai aur har tarah se isay jaiz qarar daine ki nakaam koshish ki jaa rahi hai aur koi prove nahi dia jaa rhaa aur kisi b tarah se apni baat ki back up support k liye koi Qurani ya hadees ki koi baat hi nahi hai.
Mere pyaray bhai aap har baat k aagay aur haar baat k peechay maslak maslak bol dete ho yahan par mai ne aur naa hi Anwar ne kabhi maslak ka bola hai aur na hi ham maslak ki behas mai parhna chahte hain kyun k maslak par baat karna allow nahi hai baat to Quran aur sunnat ki hai aur ham ne yeh kaha hai k aap apne is amal ko Quran aur hadees se sabit kar dain to is mai maslak kahan se aa gaya aur aap hi deobandi aur wahabi kehna hamay shoroo kar dia aur topic se hat kar is maslay ko uljhane ki koshish karne lag gae.
Mere nannay munnay bhai aap hamari har baat ka jawab dene se qasir rah gae hain aur har baat k jawab mai kabhi aap deeni mualmlaat ko dunyawi muamlaat se jor dete hain kabhi aap airaab lagane k amal ko bidaat qaraar de dete hain to kabhi aap month ko fix karne k jawab mai birthday ko jaiz qaraar de dete hain to kabhi aap bidaat k baray mai sahi hadees ko nazar aandaaz kar dete hain to kabhi aap ghair ullah k zabeehe k baray mai paish karda Qurani ayaat ko hi nazar andaaz kar dete hain.
Isliye aap say behas karna bekaar hai agar aapnay zid nahi chorni aur apni inhi baton par rahna hai aur behas baray behas jaari rakhni hai to aap apne ulamaa se kuch new cheezain seekh kar aayin kyun k aap ko bataen maloom thin wo poori ho chukin aur in sab baton se aap galaat saabit ho chuke Quran aur hadees ki roshni mai Alhamdulillah. Aur agar aap ne seedhi raah apnani hai aur rahe haq pai chalna hai to apne ulama se jaa kar kahin k giyarhveen ko Quran aur hadees ki roshni mai prove karain, Insha Allah wo nahi kar sakainge aur Aur hidayat aapki muqaddar hogi, Insha Allah.
Mere Intehai bhole bhale, seedhe saadhe, aur intehaai shareeful mizaaj Arsalan Attari bhai mai aapki baton ki kiaa daad doon, zubaan ruk jaati hai, aqal dang rah jaati hai, haath tham jaate hain aur shashdar o pareshaani k alam mai sirf yeh kehna chahoonga k Allah Talah aap logon ko aqale saleem ata farmaye aur deen ki baton ko dil aur dimaag khol kar aur Allah aur uskay Rasool SAWW ki baton ko ahmiat dene ki taufeeq ata farmaye, Aameen.
Attari bhai jaan aapki post mai parh rha thaa lekin jawab dene ka mood nahi ho rha thaa kyun k aap ne is tarah ki baten ki hain jo kisi bache ki hoti hain aur jaise koi bacha jawab deta hai aur apne bachkana dalael de kar manane ki koshish karta hai aur agar bare usay sach bataen to wo apni baat par hi qaim rahta hai aur zid karta hai bilkul isi tarah aap ne batain ki hain aur Quran shareef aur sahi ahadees ki hawala jaat saamnay daikhne k baad b aap k kaan par joon tak na raingi hai aur aap murg ki aik taang k mutaradif apni baat par atal hain.
Arsalan Attari bhai sahab aap ne jo birthday wali baat ki hai us par to mai shashdar hoon k aap ne yeh kiaa baat ki hai, O mere bhai jaan saray maslak k ulamaa is baat par muttafiq hain k Birthday kisi b tarah se jaaiz nahi hai to yeh kia baat hui k aap Abdul Qadir Jilani ki birthday mana rahe ho yeh aap nay daleel di hai date aur month ko fix karne ki wah waaaaaaaaaah kia baat hai aap ki sadqe jaaon.
Meri sheereen mizaaj bhai aap ne jo fatwa yahan paste kia hai, mere bhai aap yeh batana pasand karainge k yeh kin sahab ka hai aur yeh kaisa fatwa hai jis mai aik b Quran ka hawala yaa Saha sitta se koi baat nahi hai aur sirf jaiz hai jaiz hai ki rat lagi hui hai aur har tarah se isay jaiz qarar daine ki nakaam koshish ki jaa rahi hai aur koi prove nahi dia jaa rhaa aur kisi b tarah se apni baat ki back up support k liye koi Qurani ya hadees ki koi baat hi nahi hai.
Mere pyaray bhai aap har baat k aagay aur haar baat k peechay maslak maslak bol dete ho yahan par mai ne aur naa hi Anwar ne kabhi maslak ka bola hai aur na hi ham maslak ki behas mai parhna chahte hain kyun k maslak par baat karna allow nahi hai baat to Quran aur sunnat ki hai aur ham ne yeh kaha hai k aap apne is amal ko Quran aur hadees se sabit kar dain to is mai maslak kahan se aa gaya aur aap hi deobandi aur wahabi kehna hamay shoroo kar dia aur topic se hat kar is maslay ko uljhane ki koshish karne lag gae.
Mere nannay munnay bhai aap hamari har baat ka jawab dene se qasir rah gae hain aur har baat k jawab mai kabhi aap deeni mualmlaat ko dunyawi muamlaat se jor dete hain kabhi aap airaab lagane k amal ko bidaat qaraar de dete hain to kabhi aap month ko fix karne k jawab mai birthday ko jaiz qaraar de dete hain to kabhi aap bidaat k baray mai sahi hadees ko nazar aandaaz kar dete hain to kabhi aap ghair ullah k zabeehe k baray mai paish karda Qurani ayaat ko hi nazar andaaz kar dete hain.
Isliye aap say behas karna bekaar hai agar aapnay zid nahi chorni aur apni inhi baton par rahna hai aur behas baray behas jaari rakhni hai to aap apne ulamaa se kuch new cheezain seekh kar aayin kyun k aap ko bataen maloom thin wo poori ho chukin aur in sab baton se aap galaat saabit ho chuke Quran aur hadees ki roshni mai Alhamdulillah. Aur agar aap ne seedhi raah apnani hai aur rahe haq pai chalna hai to apne ulama se jaa kar kahin k giyarhveen ko Quran aur hadees ki roshni mai prove karain, Insha Allah wo nahi kar sakainge aur Aur hidayat aapki muqaddar hogi, Insha Allah.