Don bhai aap ki baat baja ,lekin meiN bina sanad o reference k pesh karda rivayat par yaqeen nahi rakhta. aap ki pesh karda rivayat k barey meiN meiN nahiN janta k wo "matwatar" ya sahih hai k nahiN.meiN to itna janta hooN k hazrat umar ne khud rasool saww k bataye huve qavaneen meiN tarameem keiN.
sunan abu dawood , hadith : 437
"Rasool allah saww k zamaney meiN sharab ki hadd(saza) 40 durrey thi , hazrat abu bakr k dor meiN bhi yehi saza raiej rahi , hazrat umar ibn e khattab ne 80 durrey kar diye"
kia ye qanoon e khuda aur qanoon e rasool saww meiN tarmeem nahiN?? agar salman taseer ne qanoon meiN tarmeem ka mutaliba kia to hazrat umar k barey meiN kia khayal hai aapka , salman taseer to gustaakh e rasool hai , aur ussey saza bhi mil gai aur hazrat umar???
ek aur rivayat pesh e khidmat hai ,
"abdullah ibn e umar ibne khattab se kisi ne ne umra e tamt'a (mutaah e umra) k barey meiN poocha to unhoN ne kaha jaiez hai , phir sawal karne wale ne kaha k tumharey baap , umar ibn e khattab to mana kartey thay , to abdullah ibn e umar ne kaha bhala dekh to sahi , agar mera baap mana karey aur rasool saww wahi kaam kareiN to mere baap ki tab'edaari ki jaaye gi ya rasool saww ki? to saiel ne jawab dia k rasool saww ki"
iss wazeh wazeh rivayat ko paRhne k baad aap ki kia roy hai ?? hazrat umar k apne beTey abdullah ibn e umar keh rahe heiN k unn k walid hazrat umar ne rasool saww k hukm k khilaaf hukm dia , aur rasool saww ne umra e tamt'a ko jaiez qarar dia aur hazrat umar ne uss ko najaiez. aur ye rivayat "tavatur" k sath hai , ilm e hadees rakhne waley jantey heiN k "matwatar" hadees kisey kehte heiN.
aik aur hadees arz karta hooN ,
hazrat umar tehreef e quraan k qaiel thay , mota imam malik : page 594
"umar ibn e khattab ka kehna k ayat e rajm quraan meiN mojood thi "
ek aur jaga hazrat umar ne kaha k ayat e rajm quraan meiN mojood thi jo k ab nahiN hai ,
quraan meiN allah ne hifazat e quraan ka zimma khud lia hai , lehaaza islam meiN tehreef e quran ka aqeeda rakhne wala murtadd hai aur gustakh e rasool o gustaakh e khuda hai ... maazrat k sath , ye sab meiN nahiN keh raha balkeh imam malik sihaah e sittah ki ek motabar kitaab mota meiN keh rahey heiN.
ek aur rivayat arz karta chalooN ,
sahih bukhari , jild: 1, hadith : 867 , page 381
"zahri rivayat kartey heiN k juma k din pehli azaan is waqt hoti thi jab imam minbar par beTh jata tha , rasool allah saww , hazrat abu bakr , aur hazrat umar k zamaney tak isi tarah hua , jab khilafat e hazrat usman shuru hui to hazrat usman ne juma k din teesri aazan dene ka hukm dia aur phir ye silsila chalta raha"
Don bhai , ab aap ka kia khayal hai ?? ek puri ki puri aazan meiN izafa karna yani hukm e rasool saww meiN tarmeem karna jaiez hai ya na jaiez?? agar jaiez hai to salman taseer ghalat kyuN ? aur agar najaiez hai to hazrat usmaan...??? felsa khud suna dijiye ga ab soch k ...
mere khayal se itni rivayaat kafi heiN aap ki tasalli k lye.
meiN maslak o maktab k havaley se "tehqeeq" ka qaiel hooN na k "taqleed" ka. aap agar gustaakhi ki bat kareiN to wo konsi aisi gustakhi e rasool saww hai jo bukhari meiN mojood nahiN??? meiN ne jab inn kutub ka mutalia kia to mere rongTey khaRey ho gaye ...
ab aap ne baat cher hee di hai to aap ko kuch aur tohfey bhi diye chalta hooN ,
sahih bukhari jild :1 , hadith :213 meiN rasool saww ne farmaya k peshaab ki cheentoN se parhaiz na karna sakht gunah aur sabab e azaab hai.
ye rivayat page 175 pe hai , page 177 par ek hadees mulahiza kijiye :
ye hadees likhtey huve meri ungliyaaN kaanp rahi heiN k imam bukhari ne itni baRi gustakhi likhi shan e aqdas meiN ..
Naozobillah,
" rasool allah saww kisi qoum k kooRa karkat dalne wali jagha par tashreef laaye aur khaRey ho k peshaab kia "
allah o akbar ! ab aap khud fesla kijiye , pehle wali hadees meiN rasool allah ek kaam ko gunah keh rahey heiN aur imam bukhari aur unn ko manney waloN k mutabiq ussi kaam ko khud anjaam de rahey heiN (maazallah) yani aap saww (naozobillah , naql e kufr , kufr nabashd) ne gunah anjam dia ...
meiN nahiN samajhta k iss se baRi gustaakhi aap ki shan meiN koi kar sakta hai , ham log kafiroN par to tanqeedeiN kartey heiN lekin apney girebaan nahiN dekhte.kaafiroN ne bhi inhi kitaboN se parh parh kar gustaakhiyaN ki heiN.
agar koi ek hadees ho to meiN tasleem bhi karuN puri sahih bukhari iss tarah ki gustaakhiyaN mojood heiN bukhari jild :1 hadees : 392 meiN likha gaya hai k rasool allah saww ne ek dafa bhool kar zohar 4 rakatoN ki bajaye 5 rakateiN paRha di.(naozobillah)
ab mujhe bataiye kia ye kisi gustaakhi se kam hai ?? aap jin kitaboN par eeman rakhtey heiN jo kitaab aap ki motabar tareen kitaab hai uss meiN rasool saww k barey meiN kia kia likha hai ??? kia rasool saww ko gunahgaar sabit karna gustaakhi nahiN???
phir bhoolna to darkinaar , isi jild meiN hadees : 565 meiN likhaa gaya hai k rasool saww ki nimazeiN aksar qaza ho jati theiN (naozobillah)
woh rasool saww jinhoN ne hameiN nimaazeiN sikhaaeiN unn k barey meiN aisa kehna k un ki nimaz qaza ho jati thi gustaakhi nahiN???
wo rasool jin k ahl e bait k barey meiN quraan keh raha hai k nijasat o rijs inn se door hai to rasool ko gunahgar sabit karna (naozobillah) gustaakhi nahiN???
phir sahih bukhari jild 1 hadees : 2467 meiN rasool allah k barey meiN likha gaya hai k (naozobillah) ek dafa quraan kareem ki tilawat kartey huve rasool allah saww ayateiN bhool gaye aur kisi ne unheiN ayateiN yaad karwaeiN (ma'azallah , mere muNh meiN khaak)
wo rasool saww jin k qalb pe quraan nazil hua unheiN quran ki ayateiN bhool jana aur iss par waaye ye k aik ghair masoom ka unheiN ayateiN yad karwana....kia ye gustaakhi nahiN ???
rasool allah saww k barey meiN "gunah" aur "khata" ka tasavvur karne wala hee murtad o kafir ho jata hai aur waaey ho inn musalmanoN par jinki kitab meiN kia kia gustaakhiyaN ki gai heiN...
don bhai and tooba , meri iss tamam tarr tamheed ka maqsad ye hai k ham wo heiN jinhoN ne dusroN par tanqeed karna seekha hai ,kabhi apne girebaan meiN jhaank kar nahiN dekha , hamarey naaam nihaad molvi o mulla hameiN apne matlab ki rivayateiN to sunatey heiN aur jab koi gustakhi karey ussey qatl karne k fatwey bhi detey heiN magar kabhi ye hadeeseiN bayan keiN?? aur aam musalman ko to bukhari kia , quraan ko paRhne aur samajhne ki bhi toufeeq nahiN hoti , abhi to meiN ne chand rivayateiN bayan ki heiN bukhari bhari paRi hai aisi hadeesoN se.
ab aap khud fesla kijiye , ya to bukhari o hazrat umar ko ghalat qarar de dijiye ya rasool saww ko naozobillah "khata kaar" aur "gunahgaar" maan lijiye ...!!!
inn rivayatoN ko paRhne k baad mera imaan to uth gaya hai bukhari aur iss k manney waloN se , meiN to kehta hooN qanoon tahaffuz namoos e risalat k tehet imam bukhari aur uss k tamam manney waley molvi aur jo iss kitaab par eman rakhtey heiN woh sab hee gustaakh e rasool saww heiN , inn sab ko mout ki saza deni chahye.salman taseer kam az kam inn munafiqoN ki tarah to nahiN tha uss ne qanoon meiN tarmeem ka mutalba kia aur sahih bukhari k peshwa naozobillah rasool saww ko gunahgar sabit kar rahey heiN.
iss havale se atleast muje "ahl e tashayyo" k aqaied tarjeehan mustanad nazar aaney lagtey heiN jin k nazdeek rasool saww masoom heiN unn k barey meiN gunah ka tasavvur karne se hee islam se insan kharij ho jata hai.meiN ne unnki tamam tarr kitaboN ka mutalia kia hai aur yaqeen kijiye , unn ki kitaboN meiN aisi koi rivayat nahiN mili mujhe jis meiN aanhazrat k barey meiN gustaakhi ki gai ho.
wama alaina illal balaghul mubeen...
---------- Post added at 06:54 PM ---------- Previous post was at 06:49 PM ----------
tooba khan se meri guzaarish hai k tehzeeb k daiera meiN rehte huve baat kareiN , meiN na to badtahzeeb logoN se bat karta hooN na unko bardaasht karta hooN ,meiN deen k havale se koi bhi baat solid proof aur reference k sath karta hooN , agar aap daleel k sath baat nahiN kar sakteiN to khamosh rahye aur apni "sukhan e nayaab" ko apni hadd tak mehdood rakheiN.
mohdbin qasim aur tooba , apke tamam tarr savalaat k jawab meri above post meiN mojood heiN.
tum nay jiS tarah baat ka rukh badla Os say mujhe pehlay hi andaza hOgaya tha k Tum Shia hO Or aakhir may tum nay Saboot bhi dedia
iss havale se atleast muje "ahl e tashayyo" k aqaied tarjeehan mustanad nazar aaney lagtey heiN jin k nazdeek rasool saww masoom heiN unn k barey meiN gunah ka tasavvur karne se hee islam se insan kharij ho jata hai.meiN ne unnki tamam tarr kitaboN ka mutalia kia hai aur yaqeen kijiye , unn ki kitaboN meiN aisi koi rivayat nahiN mili mujhe jis meiN aanhazrat k barey meiN gustaakhi ki gai ho.
aap ki ittela k liyeh Arz hai yeh thread Salman taSeer Or Qadri k baray may banai gai hai k kiSsi Sahabi ya Hozoor S.A.W.W k baray may nahi banai gai
aap ki bari meharbani hOgi k aap iS thread may kiSsi Sahabi k ya Hozoor S.A.W.W k baray may baat na karay Sirf Salman Taseer Or Qadri baray may hi baat karain
iss havale se atleast muje "ahl e tashayyo" k aqaied tarjeehan mustanad nazar aaney lagtey heiN jin k nazdeek rasool saww masoom heiN unn k barey meiN gunah ka tasavvur karne se hee islam se insan kharij ho jata hai.meiN ne unnki tamam tarr kitaboN ka mutalia kia hai aur yaqeen kijiye , unn ki kitaboN meiN aisi koi rivayat nahiN mili mujhe jis meiN aanhazrat k barey meiN gustaakhi ki gai ho.
aap ki ittela k liyeh Arz hai yeh thread Salman taSeer Or Qadri k baray may banai gai hai k kiSsi Sahabi ya Hozoor S.A.W.W k baray may nahi banai gai
aap ki bari meharbani hOgi k aap iS thread may kiSsi Sahabi k ya Hozoor S.A.W.W k baray may baat na karay Sirf Salman Taseer Or Qadri baray may hi baat karain